Many users of expensive papers for drawing, printmaking, and watercolor painting have been deluding themselves for years in believing they have been buying and using handmade papers when, in fact, they have been purchasing mould-made papers (made by machine) containing varying percentages of rag content. (The differences between machine-made, mould-made, and handmade papers will be explained later.)
Show a prospective customer a deckle edge and whisper, “rag content,” and you have a buyeralbeit an ignorant one. Yet, there is nothing wrong with mould-made paper; some of my best prints were and are made on it, and many of my best friends-to overwork an overworked cliche-still use Antique Laid, German Copperplate, English Etching, Arches, Rives BFK, and other mould-made paper for prints, drawings, and watercolors and are delighted with their results. Compare any mould-made paper with handmade, however, and a different story results, which will unfold as we continue.
In the not-too-distant past, there was a plentiful supply of inexpensive handmade paper. Mills employed highly skilled craftsmen to replenish their stocks of paper for sale around the world. Unfortunately, the overwhelming majority of these old paper mills have closed down, victims of the technological revolution, for lack of young recruits to the craft, rising costs, inflation, and steadily decreasing profit margins.
In 1886, Charles Thomas Davis wrote, “There is now so little handmade paper produced in the United States that a chapter devoted to the details of its manufacture is really of no practical value…” Except for a gaggle of handmade paper mills in various countries, including the United States and Canada, Mr. Davis’ statement still standsthough it appears to be threatened by the present rediscovery of paper and pulp as mediums for artists.
Current economic realities have forced the small number of mills in operation in North America to price their handmade papers at high levels. In defense of present-day costs of handmade paper, here are some observations by Henry Morris, papermaker, printer, publisher, and sole proprietor of the well known and highly esteemed Bird & Bull Press: “Actually, the New York prices of English handmade paper, as late as 1968, were too low to provide a fair return to the mills. I did a little research on the subject of prices and was surprised to learn that when adjusted to real purchasing power, the price of a ream of 20 x 25 inch handmade paper was actually 30 % lower in 1968 than the same ream in 1928. Since 1968 there have been several increases, and using the same yardstick, I believe this paper is now properly priced and includes a sufficient profit for the makers. The question arises as to whether the market will support these prices which, although high, are necessary and reasonable under present-day conditions.” (Morris, “Letter to the Editor.” Fine Print, Vol. 2, NO.2. April, 1976, p. 20.)
Given a choice, professional artists prefer handmade paper to all substitutes. A visit to any historical collection of prints and drawings will bear eloquent witness to the previous statement.